Each year, Fulton Lodge No. 216, F. & A. M. presents an award to an Outstanding Brother of the Year. Each year, the Award is presented in memory of a deceased Brother of Fulton Lodge.
The Award is presented to a member of Fulton Lodge whose activities emulate Masonry as demonstrated primarily in the member’s service performed on behalf of Fulton Lodge, and a recipient can receive the Award only once. Previous awards were as follows:
| Year | Brother of the Year | Dedicated To |
| 2025 | Hosea DeMarzino | Dr. David (Rabbi) Marx, P. M. |
| 2024 | Robert Anglin | Maurice Krugman, P. M. |
| 2023 | Steven Henry Schwartz, P. M. | Mendle Boorstin, P. M. |
| 2022 | Eliot (Bubba) Taratoot | Steve Marcus, P. M. |
| 2020 | Michael Greenfield | Joe Willie Gerstein, P. M. |
| 2019 | Adam Brodofsky, P. M. | MWB Joseph P. Suttles (Honorary) |
| 2018 | Guy Rappaport, P. M. | MWB Al Garner (Honorary) |
| 2017 | William G. Loventhal, III, P. M. | Henry Leff |
| 2016 | A. Jack Fishman, P. M. | Emanuel “Manny” Berkowitz |
| 2015 | Alvin Hazan, P. M. | Robert I. Freedman, P. M. |
| 2014 | Stanley M. Baum, P. M. | Jacob Isaac Hazan, P. M. |
| 2013 | Sam Garcia, P. M. | Clarence Autry, P. M. |
| 2012 | Tom Bruce, P. M. | Meyer Levy, P. M. |
| 2011 | Alan Cannon | Jerry H. Fields |
| 2010 | Ross Laver, P. M. | Arthur Kaplan |
| 2009 | Randy Hazan, P. M. | Sheldon Little, P. M. |
| 2008 | Michael Hickey, P. M. | Arthur Wasser, Jr., P. M. |
| 2007 | Michael A. Kessler, P. G. M. and Dr. F. Robert Ginsberg, P. M. | Sylvain Lidsky, P.M. |
| 2005 | Erwin Schwarz | Charles O. Baird, Jr., P. M. |
| 2004 | Ron Ladd, P. M. | Archie Shub |
| 2003 | Marvin Mitchell | Emanuel “Manny” Rubin, P. M. |
| 2002 | Jason Hoffman | Frank Kaufmann |
| 2001 | Raymond Yarfitz | M. Ronald Boorstin, P. M. |
| 2000 | Morris Zimmer | Sidney Parks, P. M. |
| 1999 | Lon Goodman | Charles D. Walker, P. M. |
| 1998 | Ernst Braun | Fred Kern |
| 1997 | Phillip S. Levy | Solomon Beton, P. M. |
| 1996 | William H. Sachs | Louis Cohen, P. M. |
| 1995 | G. Frank Loewy | Morris Goldberg, P. M. |
| 1994 | Benjamin Gross | Abe Levetan |
| 1993 | P. Ellis Hogue | Norman H. Diamond, P. M. |
